Killing Life: Targeting Doctors, Hospitals in Gaza

After more than 14 months of the war of extermination on Gaza, the Israeli army continues to target Palestinian medical teams through killing, arrests, torture and disappearances.

The latest is the martyrdom of 31-year-old Thabat Ibrahim Muhammad Salim, a volunteer doctor at Al-Aqsa Martyrs Hospital in Deir al-Balah in central Gaza, on 5 January, 2025.

Since the onset of the extermination war the Israeli army has been continuously targeting hospitals and purposely breaking down the health care system.

The Israeli attacks are not limited to health facilities, but include medical staff of doctors, nurses, medical technicians  and routinely subjecting them to arrest, imprisonment and torture. Dr. Hussam Abu Safiya, director of the Kamal Adwan Hospital, who was forcibly taken away since 27 December, 2024, is the best witness of this after he refused to heed to Israeli calls for the forced evacuation of the hospital.

The attacks on Gaza are constant. Last  Sunday evening, the Israeli warplanes attacked the Abu Jarbou family home in Block 1 in the Nuseirat camp in central Gaza resulting in the martyrdom of four women, including Dr. Thabat Salim. She was greatly mourned.

Dr. Muhammad Halas shared a picture of Dr. Thabat working in the neonatal department, and accompanied it with a comment about the dedication of the late doctor: “Dr. Gaza Thabat Salim, worked without a salary and tirelessly, suffered from hunger, fear, cold and hope. Thebat is a real doctor to the point of martyrdom.”

Director-General of the Health Ministry Dr. Munir Al-Barash said on the X platform: “Dr. Thabat Salim, born in 1994, is a distinguished nursery doctor who mastered the skills and procedures of premature babies amidst the harsh conditions of war. She worked faithfully for nearly a year, before she was martyred a short while ago as a result of the Israeli occupation army’s bombing of a house in the Nuseirat camp.”

Journalist Wael Abu Omar wrote: “Thabat Salim, a doctor and Quran memorizer, studied medicine abroad and is fluent in three languages: Russian, Ukrainian and English. Fate took her to her friend’s house after finishing her work at Al-Awda Hospital, and while she was eating lunch, the house was targeted by the Israeli warplanes. She was identified by her hand only.”

The series of focused attacks on the health sector and its cadres in this war is clear that the aim by the Israelis is to dismantle and destroy this sector entirely as a central part of its military strategy to kill life in the present and future of the Gaza Strip.

Palestinian-British doctor Ghassan Abu Sitta is leading a project through the Institute for Palestine Studies to document the targeting and destruction of the health sector in Gaza. He explains the targeting of the health sector is a main pillar of Israel’s failed plan to permanently displace the residents of the Gaza Strip, starting from the north and moving on to the rest of the regions. The occupation’s targeting of all vital sectors, and not limiting it to the destruction of the health and medical facilities, shows that the occupation aims to create a war environment to destroy life as a whole and not just the health sector.

Claiming militarization of hospitals

Since the first days of the extermination war, the Israeli occupation authorities sought to erase the Palestinian population of Gaza by making the Strip unfit for life, and what better way than to target and annihlate  the health sector.

On 9 October, 2023, on the third day of the war, the Israeli occupation bombed the Beit Hanoun Hospital in northern Gaza, causing extensive damage. This was the beginning of a series of direct targeting of health sector facilities.

Five days after the bombing of the Hospital, the occupation army bombed the Oncology Diagnostic Center at the Al-Ahli Baptist Hospital in Gaza City. Through phone calls to the directors of 22 hospitals in the northern Gaza Strip, the occupation gave “orders” to evacuate them. Everyone, including the working crews there, refused to comply with the evacuation order, and insisted on keeping the health sector operating in light of the war as a professional, moral, and national necessity.

Experts say what is happening in the Gaza Strip, from targeting medical personnel and systematic destruction of the health sector, is not a historical precedent, but has been happening for years within the context of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, “but the precedent is actually in the form and extent of the destruction.”

The common factor between every storming of a Palestinian camp, village or town is blocking the road to ambulances and paramedics, preventing them from reaching the wounded, and blocking the roads between the storming area and health centers, which leads to an increase in the death toll.

Looking at the process of targeting some hospitals clearly reveals the systematic intention to destroy the health sector in total. The occupation army follows a similar methodology in every hospital: first, they throw allegations these hospitals serve as pockets for Palestinian resistance, orders for the hospital administration to evacuate, then bomb the hospital’s surroundings, then direct bombing, imposing a tight siege, then storming these facilities, destroying the whatever is left of the infrastruction, then grab and frequently kill the people inside.

In some cases, the occupation shortens the siege phase and moves directly to destroying, as it did in Beit Hanoun, Algerian Specialized, and International Eye Hospitals, and even went further to directly liquidating doctors, kidnapping them, and forcible disappearance.

1000 Medical Staff

According to Ministry of Health data published last September, Palestine lost about 1000 health workers, including specialist doctors, surgical and anesthesia technicians, nurses, physical therapy, paramedics, radiology and medical analysis technicians and expert administrators in the field of health sector management. The data also shows the occupation forces arrested and forcibly kidnapped more than 300 people.

Exhausted after a long day of injuries

The killing of Dr. Thabat Salim came within the framework of a series of continuous attacks since the beginning of the war of extermination. In April 2024, Dr. Adnan Al-Barsh, one of the most prominent surgeons in Gaza and head of the orthopedics department at Al-Shifa Hospital, was arrested by Israeli forces. He was transferred to Ofer Prison where he was subjected to severe torture that led to his martyrdom.

Dr. Mohammed Abu Salmiya, director of Al-Shifa Hospital and one of the most prominent doctors in Gaza, was arrested by Israeli forces on November 23, 2023, during the war on Gaza. Abu Salmiya spent more than seven months in Israeli prisons, where he was subjected to harsh conditions. After his release in July 2024, he spoke about his suffering inside the prisons, describing the conditions as the worst since 1948, calling for serious international action to free Palestinian prisoners.

In October 2023, Dr. Omar Saleh Farwana, the dean of the Faculty of Medicine at the Islamic University, was martyred in an Israeli bombing that targeted his home, killing 16 members of his family. He was the dean of the Faculty of Medicine at the Islamic University, and had more than 30 years of experience in treating infertility and IVF.

A day earlier, on October 14, Dr. Medhat Saidam, a burns doctor and surgeon at Al-Shifa Medical Complex, left the complex after seven consecutive days to check on his family, according to a statement by the Ministry of Health. Shortly after his arrival, an Israeli missile fell on the family home, killing the well-known doctor and all of his members where they remain under the rubble of their home.

On November 12, 2023, Dr. Hammam Al-Louh, a specialist in internal medicine and kidney transplantation, was killed in a bombing that targeted his home, where his father was with him.

In circumstances similar to the crime tool, scene, and victims, the medical sector lost on November 18, 2023, the director of internal medicine at Al-Shifa Complex, Dr Raafat Labad, who was one of the most prominent internal medicine and immunology doctors in the Gaza Strip.

The harvest of the Israeli war machine continued to include the head of the Department of Pathology at the Islamic University and Dar Al-Shifa Hospital, Dr. Ali Dabour, who was martyred in his home with his mother and son, and Dr. Hammam Al-Deeb, a distinguished orthopedic surgeon at the specialized clinic at the private Arab Hospital.

Assassination suspicion

Ministry of Health Director-General in Gaza Strip, Munir Al-Barsh, believes that doctors started to be  assassinated soon  after the start of the war of extermination post-October 7, 2023. He says “the most important component of life in the Gaza Strip is health, and the occupation wanted to deprive Gaza of its vital element of security, which is public health, by targeting doctors, killing hope in people’s souls and pushing them to emigrate and flee.” He explains the Gaza Strip now “needs 35 years to compensate the doctors who were killed, especially those with specific specialties.”

The Fourth Geneva Convention and its two additional protocols provided protection for the medical sector and its workers, including ambulance drivers and everyone who helps the wounded during wartime. The agreement went on to state the two conflicting parties must inform each other before the start of fighting where the hospitals are located at. While international humanitarian law stipulates that medical units should not be violated, but protected in accordance with Article 2 of the 1977 Protocol, the Israeli occupation authorities have not adhered to this since the beginning of the occupation of Palestine in 1948.

This article was reproduced from Arabic in the Palestine Information Center.

CrossFireArabia

CrossFireArabia

Dr. Marwan Asmar holds a PhD from Leeds University and is a freelance writer specializing on the Middle East. He has worked as a journalist since the early 1990s in Jordan and the Gulf countries, and been widely published, including at Albawaba, Gulf News, Al Ghad, World Press Review and others.

Related Posts

Wounders of Arabic

EDITOR’S NOTE: I wrote this article “On Arabic” in 2008 and posted on hackwriters.com. I am reprinting it here for relvance and archival use

Compared with English, Arabic is an easy read if it is written well. When you look at English, the perception of the language, written and oral, took centuries of development from archaic structures associated with the old English of Geoffrey Chaucer, passing to Shakespeare and Christopher Marlow to George Elliot, Charles Dickens, Virginia Wolfe as well as many others and not mentioning the new contemporaries.

With Arabic it’s different. Although there may have been stages of development through out the centuries, it seems the clarity of the Arabic language was a one-time affair, represented in the Holy Koran brought down from the skies through Angel Gabriel to Prophet Mohammad in the 7th century and passed on to the Muslim community.

The Koran represented a basis for the Arabic language as it is spoken and written today. Unlike English, back in the 7th century Arabic was written in a clear, transparent, effective tone that involved action, and designed from every member of the social community, rich and poor, educated and illiterate, a source of knowledge and speech and continued to be so as it passed down through the centuries.

With English it was different. First if all, the language itself was derivative from other linguistic structures like Germanic, Latin, and French, many of which have said this is what made it stronger; Secondly English was helped by the issue of economic development as new inventions, processes and way of doing things required the development of new words, terminologies and syntax which evolved from the 17th century onwards.

Today some have been known to criticize Arabic for failing to be innovative, or developing to meet the needs of modernization and even globalization, with its inability to produce new words and terminologies to pace with the development going on in the region and the world.

However, one of the points that has to be clarified is that as these inventions came from the western countries and as communicated in English, the language proved more flexible in coming up with new words and terms, as opposed to the Arabic language that adopted a reactive approach with linguists from the region acting haphazardly in their word formations rather than following a methodical pattern.

In the process as well, we tend to get used to hearing the words and terminologies in say the English language and when we hear their equivalents in other languages such as Arabic, as there is a sense of word creation even in translations, it becomes odd and foreign simply because our ears have got used to the English pronunciation.


But this is a different view related to globalization, how much are we as Arabs integrated into the international system, how much we take from it, what do we take, what do we buy, our consumer habits and trends and indeed, how much do we produce and contribute to world society.

While this in turn becomes related to our language, its use, how much we mix words, English-Arabic, Arabic-English, the fact of the matter is that the language itself, spoken by about 300 million people in 22 Arab countries and about a 1.5 billion in Muslim countries who read the Koran in Arabic, says a great deal.

Arabic is a cogent force, its simple, attractive and gets the point across in as a logical manner as possible. It’s easy to read and to understand. It’s structure is less complex as say French and German which are grammatically more demanding than the English language.

However, just like any other language, writing in Arabic has to be learnt, it’s a professional skill; that’s why today there is an endless beating about the bush were getting the idea across is deliberately pumped and inflated and there is much hankering because of political considerations relating to ruler, government, state, security apparatuses and so on.


These considerations are over-riding and smack directly with the professionalism of writing and the way the writing of Arabic should be as passed on and continued through out the holy Koran which is sometimes used as a source of criticism by western writers and pedagogics who claim the Arabic language lacks the basis for producing new words as do the other languages.

But when Arabic is spoken and written as part of the social community there is a sense of modernist continuum as expressed in its words, expressions, figures of speech and syntax found in the structure of the language.


Nowhere is this more emphasized than it is in the Koran. Written in the 7th century, the Koran is timeless in its spiritual message, a modernist document in its approach with words, phrases and expressions that apply as much today as when it was handed down, memorized and collectively written.

Words and expression apply as much then as they apply today. The word “car” for instance is used in one of its Suras (chapters) to signify a caravan route whereas its use today implies a vehicle, and striking the reader as if you are reading a modern document about social relations, economy, authority, and kinship.

The style of language appears to be modernist as well and not with case as it is say with the Bible that is written in old English, not as old as the language used by Chaucer, but is hard to fathom just the same.

That has proved problematic for the Koran. When translated into English translators often use the kind of language that is employed by the Bible, which does not reflect the actual modernist style of the Koran for the lucidness of the holy document becomes lost and replaced by an archaic and medieval structure once found in the language, although English has moved on tremendously.

© Marwan Asmar May 2008

Continue reading
Dad Digs For Family After Israel Bombs Their House

Hammad’s house in the Sabra neighborhood was destroyed Dec. 6, 2023, during heavy Israeli bombardment. He said a powerful bomb weighing around 2,000 pounds (907 kilograms) struck the building while the family was inside.

On a mound of sand and shattered concrete that once formed the foundation of his six-story home in Gaza City, Mahmoud Hammad digs methodically through the debris, searching for the remains of his wife and children killed beneath the rubble.

Armed with little more than a small shovel and a metal sieve, the 45-year-old father filters sand by hand, hoping to find bone fragments that would allow him to lay his family to rest.

“In the absence of machinery, this is what we have,” he said, holding up the sieve.

Home reduced to dust

Hammad’s house in the Sabra neighborhood was destroyed Dec. 6, 2023, during heavy Israeli bombardment. He said a powerful bomb weighing around 2,000 pounds (907 kilograms) struck the building while the family was inside.

He lost his wife, six children, his brother, his brother’s wife and their four children.

Hammad survived but sustained severe injuries, including multiple rib fractures and injuries to his shoulder and pelvis. After months of partial recovery, he returned to the site to begin searching for his family’s remains.

“I wanted to bury them properly,” he said.

With the help of neighbors, he managed to retrieve and bury his brother and his brother’s family. But the bodies of his wife and children remain under layers of hardened debris.

“I collect what I can, piece by piece,” he said.

Missing under the rubble

Nearly 9,500 Palestinians are missing beneath destroyed buildings across the territory, according to official estimates in Gaza.

Officials said recovery efforts are severely hindered by the lack of heavy equipment needed to clear the debris. Despite a ceasefire that took effect in October, authorities said the entry of large-scale machinery remains restricted, limiting the ability of rescue teams to reach buried bodies.

Civil defense crews have repeatedly warned that the longer debris remains uncleared, the harder it becomes to recover remains.

Private grief amid mass destruction

Hammad said his wife was pregnant and close to delivery when the strike occurred, as medical services across Gaza were collapsing under the strain of the war.

“She and our unborn child died together,” he said.

Since December, Gaza has been battered by repeated storms that further displaced families living in makeshift shelters after their homes were destroyed.

For Hammad, however, the focus remains on the ruins before him.

Each day, he returns to sift through dust and fragments of concrete, driven by what he describes as a simple duty.

“They deserve to be buried with dignity,” he said.

At least 591 Palestinians have been killed and more than 1,598 injured in Israeli attacks since a ceasefire deal took effect Oct. 10, according to Gaza’s Health Ministry.

​​​​​​​‏Israel’s war on Gaza, which began Oct. 8, 2023, and lasted two years, has killed more than 72,000 Palestinians and wounded over 171,000, most of them women and children, and destroyed about 90% of Gaza’s civilian infrastructure.

By Tarek Chouiref in Istanbul for Anadolu

Continue reading

You Missed

IRGC says Iran started its Operation True Promise 26 by launching missiles and drones against Israel

IRGC says Iran started its Operation True Promise  26 by launching missiles and drones against Israel

Iran Halts Attacks on Neighboring States Unless…

Iran Halts Attacks on Neighboring States Unless…

Iranian govt spokesman: 30% of victims are children; 165 of them killed among 1300 civilians who died by US/Israeli bombing

Iranian govt spokesman: 30% of victims are children; 165 of them killed among 1300 civilians who died by US/Israeli bombing

White House: ‘We destroyed more than 30 Iranian ships and are moving to destroying the navy completely’

White House: ‘We destroyed more than 30 Iranian ships and are moving to destroying the navy completely’

White House: ‘We Have 4 to 6 Weeks to End The Military Operations in Iran’

White House: ‘We Have 4 to 6 Weeks to End The Military Operations in Iran’

IRGC: Iran Has Not Closed The Hormuz Strait Except to Ships Linked to Israel/USA

IRGC: Iran Has Not Closed The Hormuz Strait Except to Ships Linked to Israel/USA