To Piers Morgan: How Can The Killing of Women Children Be Justified as a ‘Moral Right’

British broadcaster and journalist Piers Morgan said Israel’s killing of Palestinian civilians in Gaza, including women and children, could be justified as a “moral right.”

In an interview this week with journalist Tucker Carlson on a rooftop in Saudi Arabia’s capital, Morgan discussed several topics, including the Israeli assault in Gaza and whether the U.S. should be funding it.

Carlson condemned Israel’s bombardment of civilians for over a year, which Morgan questioned as he said such bombing ‘wasn’t evil.’

Carlson said: ‘If you’re intentionally killing civilians, you probably shouldn’t beat your chest and brag about it… maybe you can make the case that you had to do it, but you should weep.’

‘Is it evil though?’ Morgan responded, to which Carlson argued: ‘To kill civilians on purpose? I think it is. Kids and children? Yeah.’

Morgan said he could see there being a ‘moral right’ to civilian deaths in wartime, saying: ‘If there is a world war that threatens the entire world, yes.’

When Carlson called his view ‘disgusting’, he walked back and said it could be justified ‘in a pure defensive action’ as the two journalists sparred over the assault.

‘To intentionally kill noncombatants, women and children, I think we can say that’s wrong,’ he concluded.

The two journalists moved onto the issue of whether the US should continue funding Israel’s assault in Gaza, after former President Joe Biden sent at least $17.9 billion in military aid since the start of the Israeli genocide in October 2023.

After Carlson repeated his calls for the US to stop supplying aid to Ukraine in its conflict with Russia, Morgan questioned: ‘Why do you support Israel against Hamas? Why do you support giving them billions of dollars?’

‘I don’t,’ Carlson snapped back.


‘I support Israel in the sense that I really like Israel, I brought my family on vacation there… but (I support Israel) only to the extent that it helps the United States.’

Morgan said this was a hypocritical stance given his criticism of aid to Ukraine, saying his support merely ‘depends on which country’.

‘I don’t see a difference between (Israel’s bombing of Gaza) and what is happening in Ukraine,’ Morgan continued.

‘This is a long way away from America, there is no direct involvement with America or no mainland involvement, and yet you think it’s right that America supports Israel, but you don’t think it’s right that America supports Ukraine.’

Fifteen months of Israeli bombardment have reduced buildings to rubble and ash, leaving large areas of Gaza uninhabitable. More than 47,400 Palestinians were killed during the Israeli assault, with 70 percent of the victims being women and children, according to Gaza’s Health Ministry.

CrossFireArabia

CrossFireArabia

Dr. Marwan Asmar holds a PhD from Leeds University and is a freelance writer specializing on the Middle East. He has worked as a journalist since the early 1990s in Jordan and the Gulf countries, and been widely published, including at Albawaba, Gulf News, Al Ghad, World Press Review and others.

Related Posts

Trump’s Envoy Boehler: Hamas Leaders Are “Actually Pretty Nice Guys, Guys Like US”

Trump’s hostage envoy, Adam Boehler said in a CNN interview that Hamas leaders are “actually pretty nice guys; guys like us.” He defended direct U.S. talks with the resistance movement, stating, “The U.S. is not an agent of Israel.”

Boeler’s statement was made commenting on a call by Ron Dermer, Israel’s Minister of Strategic Affairs and Benjamin Netanyahu’s Right-Hand Man. Dermer has reportedly made an angry phone call criticizing Trump’s decision to start direct talks with Hamas.

Boehler began negotiations with Hamas in Qatar last week. The talks focused on securing the release of Edan Alexander, a 21-year-old Israeli-American soldier prisoner, and the remains of four American settlers killed in Gaza.

Hamas reportedly told Boehler it is willing to return all Israeli prisoners in exchange for the release of Palestinian detainees. However, Israel has not agreed on the number of detainees to be freed according to the Quds News Network.

Israel’s Growing Concern

Israel’s Channel 13 reported that senior Israeli officials are angry over Washington’s approach. They believe Trump is negotiating behind Israel’s back and limiting Netanyahu’s ability to maneuver. One source stated, “If Trump reaches a deal with Hamas, Netanyahu won’t be able to refuse it, and the Americans know that.”

At first, Netanyahu dismissed the possibility of serious U.S.-Hamas negotiations. But as talks progressed, Israeli officials became increasingly concerned.

Boehler emphasized that meeting with Hamas does not mean friendship or alliance. He clarified, “I work for President Trump. This is his decision, and I am carrying it out.”

The U.S. reportedly told Hamas that releasing American prisoners would build trust with Trump, who could then push for a broader ceasefire deal.

Israel’s Channel 13 quoted Adam Boehler saying that Hamas wants to return all Israeli prisoners and free all Palestinian detainees in return.

Continue reading

You Missed

‘Godmother’ of Illegal Settlements

‘Godmother’ of Illegal Settlements

US-Hamas Talks: Netanyahu’s Double-Wound

US-Hamas Talks: Netanyahu’s Double-Wound

Trump’s Envoy Boehler: Hamas Leaders Are “Actually Pretty Nice Guys, Guys Like US”

Trump’s Envoy Boehler: Hamas Leaders Are “Actually Pretty Nice Guys, Guys Like US”

On Hamas Talks: ‘The US Has its Own Interests’ Says Adam Boehler

On Hamas Talks: ‘The US Has its Own Interests’ Says Adam Boehler