Europe Says No to Trump’s Plan to Take Over Gaza, Transfer its People

Several European leaders, Wednesday, rejected US President Donald Trump’s controversial plan to “take over” Gaza and forcibly resettle its Palestinian population in other countries.

Germany

Dismissing the proposal, German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock said that the only way forward for peace is a negotiated two-state solution.


“It is clear that Gaza—like the West Bank and East Jerusalem—belongs to the Palestinians,” Baerbock said, warning that forcibly expelling the civilian population would violate international law and fuel further hatred.

She stressed that the UN, EU, and G7 have consistently opposed Israeli settlements on Palestinian territories.

France

France also swiftly rejected Trump’s proposal, reaffirming that Gaza should remain part of a future Palestinian state.


“The future of Gaza must be inscribed not in the perspective of control by a third State but in the framework of a future Palestinian State, under the aegis of the Palestinian Authority,” a French Foreign Ministry statement said.

“France reiterates its opposition to any forced displacement of the Palestinian population of Gaza, which would constitute a serious violation of international law, an attack on the legitimate aspirations of the Palestinians, but also a major obstacle to the two-state solution,” it added.


Britain

Responding to a question on Trump’s Gaza remark, UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer said Palestinians in Gaza “must be allowed home, they must be allowed to rebuild, and we should be with them in that rebuild on the way to a two-state solution”


Spain

Spain also joined the chorus of disapproval, with Foreign Minister Jose Manuel Albares firmly rejecting the idea of US control over Gaza.

“Gaza is the land of the Palestinian Gazans. The Palestinian Gazans must stay in Gaza,” Albares said.

Spain reaffirmed its commitment to a future Palestinian state that includes Gaza as part of its territory.


Poland

Poland’s Deputy Foreign Minister Andrzej Szejna expressed support for a two-state solution and emphasized the need for Palestinian involvement in the peace process.

“Just like in the case of Ukraine, where we say that you can’t decide about Ukraine without Ukraine, if we’re talking about the peace process. Similarly, you can’t decide about Palestine without the Palestinians. This is Poland’s position,” Szejna said.

Slovenia

Slovenian Foreign Minister Tanja Fajon criticized Trump’s comments as reflective of a “deep ignorance of Palestinian history.”


Speaking from Lebanon, Fajon warned that such proposals could lead to further unrest and violence and stressed that Palestinians completely reject the idea of being displaced from their homeland.


Scotland

Scottish First Minister John Swinney also condemned the proposal, calling any suggestion of displacing Palestinians “unacceptable and dangerous.”

Swinney emphasized that the suffering of the people in Gaza must not be exacerbated by plans for forced relocation, following months of intense violence and loss of life in the region.

Further reaction

The Palestine Solidarity Campaign (PSC) condemned Trump’s remarks, describing them as “illegal” and part of a “grotesque plan” that would lead to the mass ethnic cleansing of 2.3 million Palestinians.

“This is a blueprint for a crime of historic proportions,” said the PSC, highlighting that the plan would violate the Geneva Convention’s prohibition on the forcible transfer of populations.

The Muslim Council of Britain has criticized Trump’s plan, urging international action for Gaza’s reconstruction that is led by the Palestinian people themselves.

Wajid Akhter, Secretary General of the Muslim Council of Britain, warned that any attempt to reconstruct Gaza through displacement would amount to ethnic cleansing.

“Reconstruction without displacement is not only possible – it is the only acceptable path forward,” he stated.

Amnesty Denmark

Amnesty Denmark echoed the widespread rejection, with spokesperson Vibe Klarup drawing a stark comparison between Trump’s plan and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

” (What) Trump is advocating here is, first of all, a real invasion of another people’s country,” Klarup said, adding that any US takeover of Gaza would be criminal and a grave breach of international law.

During a news conference with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in Washington on Tuesday, Trump said that the US “will take over” Gaza after relocating Palestinians elsewhere under a redevelopment plan that he claimed could turn the enclave into “the Riviera of the Middle East,” according to Anadolu.

CrossFireArabia

CrossFireArabia

Dr. Marwan Asmar holds a PhD from Leeds University and is a freelance writer specializing on the Middle East. He has worked as a journalist since the early 1990s in Jordan and the Gulf countries, and been widely published, including at Albawaba, Gulf News, Al Ghad, World Press Review and others.

Related Posts

Palestinian Dr Held Over Social Media Posts Suffers Heart Attack in Israeli Detention

CROSSFIREARABIA — Palestinian gynecologist Dr Dima Amin, a well-known physician from Ramallah, remains in Israeli detention after being arrested over social-media posts, despite suffering a serious cardiac episode while in custody that required emergency heart catheterization.

An Israeli military court extended the 55-year-old doctor’s detention for another five days on Sunday, 23 August, according to Palestinian media reports. The case has prompted growing concern over both her treatment in custody and Israel’s increasing use of social-media activity as grounds for arresting Palestinians according to the Palestine Information Center.

Dr Amin was seized in the early hours of 18 August after Israeli forces raided her home in the Al-Tireh neighbourhood of Ramallah.

WAFA, the official Palestinian news agency, reported that Israeli troops entered the house and searched and disturbed its contents before taking her away. A WAFA report outlines that Dr Amin is an obstetrician and gynecologist who has practiced in Ramallah for decades.

Her husband, Dr Haider Abu Ghosh, told Palestinian media that the raid took place at approximately 2:15 a.m. and that soldiers forced their way through the main entrances to the building before arresting his wife. Palestinian reports said she also works with the Dunya Women’s Cancer Center and maintains a private medical practice in Ramallah.

For approximately a day and a half following the arrest, her family and lawyer reportedly did not know where she was being held.

Then came news that her health had deteriorated dramatically.

According to the Palestinian Information Center, Dr Amin said she was subjected to mistreatment after her arrest and that her hands were bound extremely tightly. Her requests for the restraints to be loosened because of her condition were allegedly refused.

Her health subsequently deteriorated and she suffered what was described as an acute cardiac episode. She was transferred to Hadassah Hospital in Jerusalem, where doctors performed a cardiac catheterization.

Despite the seriousness of the episode and the invasive cardiac procedure, Palestinian reporting says Israeli authorities returned her to detention shortly afterwards rather than releasing her for recovery and medical monitoring.

The allegations of harsh treatment are particularly troubling given that Dr Amin had just suffered a potentially life-threatening medical emergency. Palestinian reports describe severe restraint and mistreatment during her detention. At the time of publication, however, CrossfireArabia could not independently verify Palestinian social-media claims that she was beaten, and available Palestinian news reports examined for this article do not provide sufficient detail to state that allegation as established fact.

Detained Over Facebook Posts

The case is not based on allegations that Dr Amin carried a weapon or participated in an armed attack.

Palestinian reports say the investigation centres on material she posted or shared on social media, particularly Facebook. Israeli authorities reportedly accuse her of offences relating to “incitement”, supporting a hostile organisation and harming security.

The Palestinian Information Center reported that the military court nevertheless ordered her detention extended by another five days while the investigation continues.

The case consequently raises a much broader question: How far can Israel go in imprisoning Palestinians for political expression online?

Palestinian activists and rights organisations have repeatedly accused Israeli authorities of monitoring Palestinian social-media accounts and interpreting posts, photographs, comments and expressions of political sympathy as grounds for arrest and interrogation.

In Dr Amin’s case, the consequences have gone far beyond questioning over Facebook posts. Within hours of being taken from her home, a 55-year-old doctor found herself in Israeli custody suffering a cardiac crisis serious enough to require a catheterization — and was then returned to detention.

Palestinian Medical Groups Condemn Arrest

The Palestinian NGO Network condemned Dr Amin’s arrest, portraying it as part of a wider pattern of Israeli action against Palestinian medical and humanitarian personnel.

Its health sector said Dr Amin’s arrest should be viewed in the context of pressure on Palestinian civil society and healthcare workers and called for immediate action to secure the release of detained medical personnel according to Raya.

The network noted that other Palestinian doctors and health workers have also been detained, and said hundreds of medical personnel — particularly from Gaza — remain in Israeli custody.

Local Palestinian media carried similar concerns from medical and civil-society figures, who stressed that Dr Amin’s professional career has centred on medicine, women’s health and humanitarian work.

For now, however, Dr Dima Amin remains behind bars.

She was taken from her Ramallah home in the middle of the night, held for many hours without her family knowing her whereabouts, subjected according to her account to harsh restraints and mistreatment, suffered a serious heart problem requiring hospitalisation and cardiac catheterization — and was then returned to Israeli custody.

And the case against her, according to the Palestinian reports, centres not on an act of violence but on what she expressed on social media.

Continue reading
Israel Violated The Ceasefire 4379 Times in 315 Days

CROSSFIREARABIA – Israel has violated the ceasefire 4379 times according to the Government Media Office in Gaza City. It has been 315 days since the Gaza ceasefire was signed on 10 October, 2025. The Office stated since that time Israeli military strikes on the Strip killed 1,286 people and injured 4,257 while 180 arrests were made by the Israeli occupation since that time.

Continue reading

You Missed

Join The Queue For The Drops

Join The Queue For The Drops

‘My Way Out of Insanity’

‘My Way Out of Insanity’

The Child, Tree and The Dark

The Child, Tree and The Dark

Palestinian Dr Held Over Social Media Posts Suffers Heart Attack in Israeli Detention

Palestinian Dr Held Over Social Media Posts Suffers Heart Attack in Israeli Detention

Israel Violated The Ceasefire 4379 Times in 315 Days

Israel Violated The Ceasefire 4379 Times in 315 Days

Gaza’s Kites Return — and Israel Katz Threatens Revenge

Gaza’s Kites Return — and Israel Katz Threatens Revenge